Oxygen Concentrator Vs Oxygen Tank: What Is the Difference?

Oxygen Concentrator Vs Oxygen Tank: What Is the Difference?

Oxygen concentrators and oxygen tanks both support patients who require supplemental oxygen therapy. Although the purpose is the same, these devices function very differently and have distinct advantages depending on lifestyle, medical needs, and long term use.

The body depends on a steady supply of oxygen for every cell to function properly. Individuals with chronic lung disease, recovery from respiratory illness, or low oxygen saturation may require continuous oxygen support. Two widely used systems for oxygen delivery are oxygen concentrators and oxygen tanks. Understanding how each works can help patients choose the best solution for their treatment needs.

This guide explains the difference between oxygen concentrators and oxygen tanks, how each device works, key pros and cons, cost considerations, safety requirements, and factors to help you decide which option is right for you.

What Is the Difference Between an Oxygen Concentrator and an Oxygen Tank?

An oxygen concentrator pulls ambient air through filters, removes nitrogen, and delivers purified oxygen to the user. As long as it has power, it continues producing oxygen and does not require refills.

An oxygen tank is a pressurized container filled with compressed or liquid oxygen. Once oxygen inside the tank is used, it must be refilled or replaced. The device relies on a regulator to control flow and release the oxygen safely.

Both systems use nasal cannulas or oxygen masks for delivery and support medical oxygen therapy for conditions like COPD, interstitial lung disease, pneumonia, or cardiac-related hypoxemia.

Which Device Is Better?

The best choice depends on the patient's condition, lifestyle, prescription, and cost factors. Some patients benefit more from tanks, while others prefer the convenience of concentrators. Healthcare providers often help determine the right match based on oxygen flow needs and mobility goals.

How They Work

Oxygen Concentrator
Uses electricity or battery power to compress air, filter nitrogen, and deliver concentrated oxygen. Options include:

  • Stationary home concentrators

  • Portable oxygen concentrators (POCs) for travel and daily movement

Oxygen Tank
Contains pre-filled medical oxygen in a high pressure cylinder or liquid form. Oxygen flows through a regulator and tubing. Once empty, the tank requires replacement or refill.

Size and Weight

Concentrator sizes vary widely.

  • Portable models weigh as little as 4 to 10 pounds and operate on rechargeable batteries

  • Home concentrators are larger and designed for continuous high flow delivery

Oxygen tanks range from small portable cylinders to large stationary tanks.

  • Small B cylinders hold around 250 liters and weigh roughly 1 kg

  • Large G cylinders can hold up to 10,000 liters and may weigh 70 kg or more

Portability and Mobility

Oxygen tanks are heavy and not permitted on commercial flights. They require special carriers and are harder to move for active patients.

Portable oxygen concentrators are generally FAA approved, work with backpacks or rolling carts, and support daily travel and activities. Home concentrators are heavier but ideal for long term stationary use.

Cost Considerations

Concentrators have a higher upfront cost but low ongoing cost since they do not require refills. They require electricity and routine maintenance like filter changes.

Oxygen tanks are cheaper initially but can become expensive over time due to refill or replacement expenses.

Insurance coverage varies, and many patients receive concentrators or tanks through Medicare, Medicaid, or private insurance rental programs.

Safety

Both systems require proper handling. Key points include:

Oxygen Tanks

  • Risk of leaks due to high pressure

  • Risk of frostbite with liquid oxygen

  • Increased fire hazard near open flames

Oxygen Concentrators

  • Must be used away from sparks, cigarettes, and heat sources

  • Requires electrical safety during home use

Never smoke near any oxygen source and follow all manufacturer instructions.

What to Consider Before Choosing an Oxygen System

Doctor Prescription
Always follow your prescribed oxygen flow settings and medical instructions.

Lifestyle and Mobility
Active patients may benefit from portable concentrators. For limited mobility or short term therapy, tanks may be suitable.

Travel Frequency
Concentrators approved for air travel are ideal for flying. Car adapters can support road trips.

Treatment Duration
Long term therapy is often more cost efficient with a concentrator. Short term needs may be appropriate for tanks.

Backup Power and Battery Life
Portable units should include extra batteries for uninterrupted therapy.

Conclusion

Both oxygen concentrators and oxygen tanks play essential roles in respiratory care. The right choice depends on medical requirements, lifestyle needs, treatment duration, and financial considerations. Work closely with your healthcare provider to select the device that supports your oxygen therapy goals safely, comfortably, and efficiently.

If you need additional help choosing oxygen equipment or want guidance on insurance, rentals, or prescription requirements, reach out to a respiratory specialist or DME provider for support.

 

Sources

 

https://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/oxygen-therapy
https://www.cdc.gov/copd/index.html
https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/oxygen-therapy/about/pac-20385164
https://www.sleepfoundation.org/oxygen-therapy
https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/treatment-tests-and-therapies/oxygen-therapy
https://www.respiratorytherapy.ca/oxygen-therapy-info

Back to blog